Wordpress - What is allowed as an id argument in register_sidebar( $args )

John Landells’ answer is good and correct.

I want to add a List of forbidden or reserved IDs – these IDs may appear on the widget config page /wp-admin/widgets.php. If you use one of these … strange things will happen due to duplicated IDs. Drag and drop will probably not work anymore. See Ticket #14466 for the most obvious case: #footer.

Update, Sept. 17.: #footer will be allowed in WP 3.5.
Update, Nov., 06.: Per ticket 14466 all widget IDs in widgets.php are prefixed with sidebar- now. The following list will be obsolete with WordPress 3.5. Probably.

Also, an ID should not start with a number, that’s invalid HTML.

Installed plugins affecting this list: Debug Bar, Debug Bar Cron, Monster Widget.

#_wpnonce_widgets
#ab-awaiting-mod
#access-off
#access-on
#adminmenu
#adminmenuback
#adminmenushadow
#adminmenuwrap
#adv-settings
#available-widgets
#collapse-button
#collapse-menu
#colors-css
#contextual-help-back
#contextual-help-columns
#contextual-help-link
#contextual-help-link-wrap
#contextual-help-wrap
#debug-bar-actions
#debug-bar-cron
#debug-bar-css
#debug-bar-info
#debug-bar-menu
#debug-bar-wp-query
#debug-menu-link-Debug_Bar_Object_Cache
#debug-menu-link-Debug_Bar_Queries
#debug-menu-link-Debug_Bar_WP_Query
#debug-menu-link-ZT_Debug_Bar_Cron
#debug-menu-links
#debug-menu-target-Debug_Bar_Object_Cache
#debug-menu-target-Debug_Bar_Queries
#debug-menu-target-Debug_Bar_WP_Query
#debug-menu-target-ZT_Debug_Bar_Cron
#debug-menu-targets
#debug-status
#debug-status-db
#debug-status-memory
#debug-status-php
#debug-status-site
#footer
#footer-left
#footer-thankyou
#footer-upgrade
#icon-themes
#menu-appearance
#menu-comments
#menu-dashboard
#menu-links
#menu-media
#menu-pages
#menu-plugins
#menu-posts
#menu-posts-domicile
#menu-settings
#menu-tools
#menu-users
#object-cache-stats
#querylist
#removing-widget
#rss-items-2
#rss-items-__i__
#rss-show-author-2
#rss-show-author-__i__
#rss-show-date-2
#rss-show-date-__i__
#rss-show-summary-2
#rss-show-summary-__i__
#rss-title-2
#rss-title-__i__
#rss-url-2
#rss-url-__i__
#screen-meta
#screen-meta-links
#screen-options-link-wrap
#screen-options-wrap
#screenoptionnonce
#show-settings-link
#tab-link-missing-widgets
#tab-link-overview
#tab-link-removing-reusing
#tab-panel-missing-widgets
#tab-panel-overview
#tab-panel-removing-reusing
#widget-10_recent-posts-__i__
#widget-11_rss-__i__
#widget-12_search-__i__
#widget-13_tag_cloud-__i__
#widget-14_text-__i__
#widget-15_widget_twentyeleven_ephemera-__i__
#widget-16_rss-2
#widget-1_archives-__i__
#widget-2_calendar-__i__
#widget-3_categories-__i__
#widget-4_nav_menu-__i__
#widget-5_links-__i__
#widget-6_meta-__i__
#widget-7_monster-__i__
#widget-8_pages-__i__
#widget-9_recent-comments-__i__
#widget-archives-__i__-count
#widget-archives-__i__-dropdown
#widget-archives-__i__-savewidget
#widget-archives-__i__-title
#widget-calendar-__i__-savewidget
#widget-calendar-__i__-title
#widget-categories-__i__-count
#widget-categories-__i__-dropdown
#widget-categories-__i__-hierarchical
#widget-categories-__i__-savewidget
#widget-categories-__i__-title
#widget-links-__i__-category
#widget-links-__i__-description
#widget-links-__i__-images
#widget-links-__i__-limit
#widget-links-__i__-name
#widget-links-__i__-orderby
#widget-links-__i__-rating
#widget-links-__i__-savewidget
#widget-list
#widget-meta-__i__-savewidget
#widget-meta-__i__-title
#widget-monster-__i__-savewidget
#widget-nav_menu-__i__-nav_menu
#widget-nav_menu-__i__-savewidget
#widget-nav_menu-__i__-title
#widget-pages-__i__-exclude
#widget-pages-__i__-savewidget
#widget-pages-__i__-sortby
#widget-pages-__i__-title
#widget-recent-comments-__i__-number
#widget-recent-comments-__i__-savewidget
#widget-recent-comments-__i__-title
#widget-recent-posts-__i__-number
#widget-recent-posts-__i__-savewidget
#widget-recent-posts-__i__-title
#widget-rss-2-savewidget
#widget-rss-__i__-savewidget
#widget-search-__i__-savewidget
#widget-search-__i__-title
#widget-tag_cloud-__i__-savewidget
#widget-tag_cloud-__i__-taxonomy
#widget-tag_cloud-__i__-title
#widget-text-__i__-filter
#widget-text-__i__-savewidget
#widget-text-__i__-text
#widget-text-__i__-title
#widget-widget_twentyeleven_ephemera-__i__-number
#widget-widget_twentyeleven_ephemera-__i__-savewidget
#widget-widget_twentyeleven_ephemera-__i__-title
#widgets-left
#widgets-right
#wp-admin-bar-a8c_developer
#wp-admin-bar-comments
#wp-admin-bar-debug-bar
#wp-admin-bar-edit-profile
#wp-admin-bar-logout
#wp-admin-bar-my-account
#wp-admin-bar-new-content
#wp-admin-bar-new-content-default
#wp-admin-bar-new-domicile
#wp-admin-bar-new-link
#wp-admin-bar-new-media
#wp-admin-bar-new-page
#wp-admin-bar-new-post
#wp-admin-bar-new-user
#wp-admin-bar-root-default
#wp-admin-bar-site-name
#wp-admin-bar-site-name-default
#wp-admin-bar-top-secondary
#wp-admin-bar-updates
#wp-admin-bar-user-actions
#wp-admin-bar-user-info
#wp-admin-bar-view-site
#wp_inactive_widgets
#wpadminbar
#wpbody
#wpbody-content
#wpcontent
#wpwrap
#zt-debug-bar-cron-css

I collected the IDs with a small plugin that can be used on any page:

<?php # -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
/* Plugin Name: T5 List IDs */
add_action( 'shutdown', function()
{ ?>
<script>
jQuery( function( $ )
{
    var els = []
    $( '[id]' ).each( function() { els.push( this.id ) } )
    els.sort()
    var pre = $( '<pre/>' ).css( 'margin','10px' ).html( '#'+els.join( '<br>#' ) )
    $( document.documentElement ).append( pre )
})
</script><?php
}
);

The sidebar ID is used to uniquely identify this specific sidebar. If you don't set it and something creates another, you could find that your sidebar moves somewhere unexpected!

It doesn't need to be numeric - you can use strings, too.