Is the result of Schmidt conditional to RH

1. It is known unconditionally that, as $x$ tends to infinity, $$\psi(x)-x=\Omega_{\pm}(x^{1/2}).\tag{$1$}$$ This is Corollary 15.4 in Montgomery-Vaughan: Multiplicative number theory I.

2. In fact Hardy and Littlewood proved the stronger result $$\psi(x)-x=\Omega_{\pm}(x^{1/2}\log\log\log x).\tag{$2$}$$ This is Theorem 15.11 in Montgomery-Vaughan: Multiplicative number theory I.

3. Schmidt (1903) proved the analogue of $(1)$ for the function $$f(x):=\sum_{k=1}^\infty\frac{1}{k}\pi(x^\frac{1}{k}).$$ His proof is essentially the same as of the above quoted Corollary: if the Riemann Hypothesis is false, then one has a better result, while if the Riemann Hypothesis is true, then one has a precise form of the stated result with an implied constant given in terms of the lowest lying zero of $\zeta(s)$. So Schmidt's result is unconditional as well, but it differs slightly from the statement attributed to him in the Wikipedia article.

4. Hardy and Littlewood (1916) attribute $(1)$ to Schmidt, and they quote it as Theorem 2.241. Precisely, they say that "This is substantially the well-known result of Schmidt". The stronger statement $(2)$ is Theorem 5.8 in their paper.

P.S. As Greg Martin kindly pointed out, $(2)$ is really due to Littlewood (1914).


It is elementary, take $K=1/30 < 1/|\rho_0|$ where $\rho_0\approx 1/2+i14.13$ is the first zero, if $\psi(x)-x\le Kx^{1/2}$ for $x$ large enough, then $x-\psi(x)+K x^{1/2}+C\ge 0$ for all $x$, where $C$ is a suitable real constant. Let $$F(s):=\int_1^\infty (x-\psi(x)+Kx^{1/2}+C) x^{-s-1}dx= \frac1{s-1}+\frac{\zeta'(s)}{s\zeta(s)}+\frac{K}{s-1/2}+\frac{C}{s}.$$ By the non-negativity of the integrand, it has a singularity at its abscissa of convergence $\sigma$. But the RHS is analytic on $(1/2,\infty)$, thus $\sigma=1/2$. And by the non-negativity again we have, as $\Re(s) \to 1/2$, $$|F(s)|\le F(\Re(s))\sim \frac{K}{\Re(s)-1/2}.$$ This contradicts that $$F(s)\sim\frac{\zeta'(s)}{s\zeta(s)}\sim\frac{1/\rho_0}{s-\rho_0}\qquad\text{as $s\to \rho_0$}.$$