Does arXiv do peer review and can a high school student submit to arXiv?

A high school student (with an endorsement as twestley laid out nicely) can publish on the arxiv, but very likely a high school student should not do this.

In my field, the arxiv is read daily by everyone in the field. There is no peer-review process, but we do self censor quite a bit. We usually circulate our research through our networks and get feedback before posting. Putting something on the arxiv that is low quality has serious impacts on your career. Your name is attached to that forever, and afaik you can't take it down and erase its history. Plus you can't undo anything to the wide audience that will see it the first day it gets posted.

In some sense, posting on the arxiv is more dangerous than going through peer-reviewed channels. If you submit something embarrassing to a journal, they won't publish it. The arxiv has no such safeguard.

Unless you know someone who you think can serve the purpose of a peer reviewer, and who can give an informed approval that your work won't be rejected by the community and reflect poorly on you, I strongly suggest you do NOT post to the arxiv. It could hurt you professionally if you end up in an arxiv-popular field. If you end up in an arxiv-unpopular field, then posting wouldn't really benefit you much either (as it's not a real journal). It's just not a good gamble.


(1) There's no requirement that you have to publish in a journal after putting a paper on arXiv. However, in my experience, most people who put something on arXiv do also submit it to a journal, although this depends on which field of science you are talking about.

(2) Arxiv is not a peer-reviewed journal, there are no editors or referees. This is why a lot of people submit to both arXiv and a journal.

(3) Probably not by themselves, but they could if they can convince an established researcher to endorse them.

Unless the student was already affiliated with a known university or research institute, they would usually have to get an "endorsement" to be able to submit. An "endorsement" means that an established researcher confirms that the paper being submitted is appropriate for an arXiv submission and that the authors have some idea what they are talking about.

If the student knows any researchers in the field they want to publish a paper in, they could ask them to have a look at their paper and give some feedback. If they agree that the paper is above a minimum standard they might agree to endorse.

If the student does not know any researchers, it is more difficult. They could find out who the experts in the field are and email them directly, in a polite manner, but should be aware that out-of-the-blue requests from someone unheard of are likely to be ignored.

There's more information about how endorsements work here: https://arxiv.org/help/endorsement

There may not be any shortcut to this. The best option might be for the student to wait, apply to study the field that interests them at university, and after learning more about the subject and getting to know some professors there, ask them if they'd be willing to look at their research. If they thought it was good, they would be able to endorse the student for submission to arXiv and give advice about the publication process in general.

Tags:

Preprint